The gun exudes coolness with a RoboCop-like appearance—the style is definitely there—but the pistol is lacking in performance. Its suppressor is only marginally effective, and the gun has one of the worst triggers on any production pistol this side of the Ring of Fire. Lastly, the QC was poor on the sample I bought through normal channels for this report.
Of course, none of these shortcomings are acknowledged by SilencerCo. In one of the most hyperbolic press releases ever written, the Maxim 9 is being heralded as if the living incarnation of John Browning had just returned to give the Utah-based company a heavenly new gun:
“The firearms industry has essentially remained untouched for centuries. We needed a change. The industry needed a change. Something more than a simple aesthetic revision or updated pistol grip. What would it take to redefine an industry built on tradition?”
This, we are told, is the greatest firearms advancement in centuries.
My first thought was that other improvements such as percussion caps, breech-loading rifles, smokeless powder, and Berdan primers must be mere baby steps compared to the great leap forward of the Maxim 9.
According to SilencerCo, the firearms industry has plodded along “untouched for centuries” with no innovation at all, never mind such novelties as Mr. Colt’s revolver, Mr. Henry’s repeater, Mr. Sharps’ rifle, or Mr. Browning’s pistol.
With any new gun, I first give it a good once-over and then see if I can figure out the mechanism without the owner’s manual. The Maxim 9 proved to be easy to understand. Removing the ammunition source and locking the slide back to make sure the chamber is clear, the first thing I notice is the unusual mechanism. The barrel is fixed to the receiver, and only the rear portion of the “slide” reciprocates, like an S&W Model 41.
The slide is attached to twin recoil-spring guide rods that are in turn fixed to the barrel/receiver group. The pistol operates with a delayed-blowback system utilizing a roller lock on the left side of the slide, similar to the roller-lock action first developed on the German MG 34 machinegun, albeit the Maxim 9 utilizes a single roller.
The grip is comfortable, well contoured, and textured with what one reviewer called “a binary pattern without the zeros.” The texturing is a series of dashes (maybe it’s Morse code without the dots) and feels secure in the hand. The grip angle lends the pistol a natural pointability, especially for this 1911-conditioned shooter.
TRIGGER FROM HELL
No, nary a manual safety, so why isn’t the trigger breaking?
Back to pulling I go, this time giving the trigger a good, healthy tug. Finally, it went “click.” The trigger was atrocious. Granted, I’m accustomed to good triggers. My Tactical Solutions 10/22 has a Kidd trigger set at 16 ounces. My Thompson/Center Contender is sub one pound. A tuned Colt 1991 .45 ACP is right at two pounds. My G.A. Precision .308 has a four-ounce trigger.
But this was beyond bad—it was dreadful. A Brownells trigger weight gauge revealed the Maxim 9’s go-button to break at between 6¾ and seven pounds.
A call to the factory to inquire what is the spec for the trigger yielded an answer of five pounds, so I can only assume the QC on their triggers is just as bad as that for their sights, which is what I came to next.
BROKEN TRITIUM INSERT
Just my luck to pick the one out of three with a broken insert. Mistakes happen, I understand, but a $1,500 gun never should’ve left the factory with a busted tritium insert.
After submitting this report, I telephoned SilencerCo as if I were just Joe Average and asked if a broken tritium insert would be covered under warranty. Customer service rep Stephen Mellen assured me it is most definitely covered and immediately issued me a Return Authorization, no questions asked. Outstanding job on customer service!
So far the Maxim 9 has earned an A+ for ease of takedown, an F for trigger action, and a D- for quality control. How will the heart of the gun, the integral suppressor, fare? The short answer: C.
SilencerCo states that the long version reduces the report of a 147-grain subsonic load to 136 dB (long) and 139 dB (short). These figures are accurate, based on independent testing.
With a 147-grain subsonic handload, Barry obtained readings of 137.18 dB on a microphone one meter to the right of the muzzle and 133.32 dB on a microphone one meter to the left of the muzzle.
Changing to the short configuration, readings of 138.86 dB and 138.26 dB were recorded right and left of the muzzle respectively.
SilencerCo’s claims are well inside the inherent variables of sound testing, so I give them an A+ for accurate advertising.
That said, a reduction of sound to their stated and verified 139 dB is nothing to crow about. The safe hearing level is universally accepted as 140 dB, meaning the Maxim 9 barely squeaks under the threshold—with subsonic ammunition. We did not test it with supersonic.Compared to 127 dB for a SureFire Ryder 9, the Maxim 9 deserves at best a C for sound reduction.
In my opinion, a pistol retailing for $1,500 should include mounting plates for the most popular MRD-type sights and a $4 piece of rail.
That said, the Maxim 9 ran flawlessly, without a malfunction. I was mildly concerned that the two operating rods over the ejection port might interfere with ejection, but the extractor/ejector is correctly tuned to throw the spent cases sideways, not up into the rods. I shot only subsonic 9mm ammunition through the pistol, specifically Super Vel subsonic Hush Puppy 147-grain FMJ.
I think the pistol is capable of better accuracy with a red dot, because my groups were horizontally strung, meaning I was not able to hold a consistent air gap around the front sight. Too bad they don’t include a mounting plate for an MRD…
I shot the Maxim 9 in its long configuration without ear protection and was not bothered. I shot an S&W M&P alongside it with a SureFire Ryder 9 suppressor and, while I could tell the Ryder 9 was quieter, it was not by much.
Assuming the sound level was about equal to what we had tested with the sound measuring equipment, I could not tell a significant difference between 127 and 136 dBs with my decidedly uncalibrated ears.
THE $64,000 QUESTION
Or does it? On the one hand, you’re not going to damage your own hearing should you have to repel boarders in a hallway. On the other hand, there’s something to be said for shock and awe. With gunfire shattering the night, my neighbors would know to call the cops, while the intruder’s cohorts would know it’s time to beat feet!
As this is written, holsters for the Maxim 9 are available from Blackhawk, Galco, and SilencerCo.
Honestly, the main reasons to buy a Maxim 9 are its coolness factor, bizarre appearance, and novel operating system. I bought a Boberg 9mm (pistol that feeds cartridges backwards from its magazine) for the same reason—a pure novelty.
Even though Jeff Cooper might say the Maxim 9 is a solution in search of a problem, I like oddball guns enough to have bought it.
SUPER VEL AMMUNITION