Sitting-High-Knee-position
Sitting High Knee position. SHK allows a similar grip and visual relationship with the gun that the shooter uses standing.

Long-range handgunning rarely receives much training effort, and consequently shooters’ ability at distance is often erratic. The standard training approach, often thrown in quickly if time allows, is to have the shooter take a knee or go prone. I’ve seen a great many shooters who actually shoot worse from kneeling than they do on their hind legs in their normal stance. I’ve never had great success in stretching out the range from prone, either.

Sitting Knee Straddle. Handgun is pulled back into the support-side leg for stability.

Talking over the last year with several trainers and very experienced teammates has revealed a similar ambivalence about pistol prone. Issues identified have ranged from zero shift with some shooters, to concerns about real-world utility due to line of sight issues that low to the ground, and generally mediocre results with operational shooters. With this in mind, I started monkeying around with other supported positions to get to the other end of the pistol’s trajectory.

Stacked-Feet
Stacked Feet: For shooters preferring to rest the butt for stability, the shoes can be drafted into service.

SITTING DOWN ON THE JOB

Sitting is the next lowest position to the ground from prone. The position has good contact with the deck for stability and is often able to clear visual obstructions to gain line of sight to the target.

Mobility into and out of position is degraded from kneeling, but similar to prone. Sitting is an extremely effective and useful rifle position for fieldwork, but the traditional open leg and cross leg variations do not translate well to the short gun.

However, if you throw away the “box” and apply similar principles, there are three nontraditional sitting positions to consider: Sitting High Knee (SHK), Sitting Knee Straddle (SKS), and Stacked Feet.

Sitting High Knee is accomplished by sitting down facing to about one o’clock offset from the target. The support-side knee is brought vertical and the firing-side leg is wrapped around the support-side ankle to stabilize the support column the high knee forms. The shooter leans forward to get his center of gravity over the seat and stabilizes the support-side tricep on the high knee, much as he would if firing a rifle from classic kneeling.

In the photo, you will notice the shooter’s head and hand positions are nearly identical to when firing standing, where 99% of familiarity and training effort are. Boom!

If the natural point of aim is set correctly, the pistol just hangs right onto target with almost no sway or wobble. For heavy-recoiling loads, the handgun is able to unlock the elbow and roll naturally, making it quite comfortable. This does add a little dwell time to the gun coming back down for a follow-up shot. I’ve shot the SHK while wearing a pack and with armor, and it works well with either as long as the shooter can lean over the center of gravity. The high knee does restrict air intake slightly, so it is not a great position if the shooter is already winded.

Sitting Knee Straddle is similar to High Knee except that as the position is assumed, the shooter pulls the back of the handgun into the front of the support- side high knee to stabilize it. The shooter will end up leaning back, essentially hanging from the braced pistol and aided by abdominal tension.

Strange-company--New-sitting-positions-let-handgunner-shoot-to-distances-where-he-actually-needs-a-spotting-scope-and-rangefinder
Strange company: New sitting positions let handgunner shoot to distances where he actually needs a spotting scope and rangefinder.

If back support is available, the SKS gets even better, allowing the abs to relax, but it is not at all required. The shooter does need to remember to breathe and not dawdle too much or the trunk muscles may start to quiver and affect the shot. If the shooter is wearing a pack or armor with bulky pouches attached to the back, the SKS may allow “built-in” back support.

SKS is pretty fast to assume and not as dependent on getting a solid natural point of aim as SHK. This position works really well with the polymer service pistols and is a great match to 9mm level recoil. The SKS recovers quickly, allowing very fast follow-up shots. Heavy loads and sharp edged guns can be a poor match here, letting the gun bite into the patellar tendon if care isn’t taken how the gun is placed. But I’ve fired heavy .44 Magnum loads from the position with only slight discomfort. The hits were worth it.

Stacked Feet is adapted directly from the similar rifle position I first saw taught by Kyle Lamb in VTAC classes. The shooter sits down with the support- side leg extended straight toward the target. The firing-side boot heel is “stacked” onto the support-side toe and the handgun’s butt is then rested onto the shooting-side toe tread. The position does require a little flexibility, but not as much as you may think.

The shooter must take care when assuming SF not to sweep his or her own feet. Similarly the shooter must be aware during recoil, as some combinations of pistol, load, and shoe tread may allow the gun to slip off the “platform” and be very near muzzling the top foot. For these downsides, the shooter gains another viable position that is tailor made for downhill shots. If the shooter has a good position, the stacked feet can recover the sights pretty quickly.

As with SHK, SF can restrict air supply a bit, requiring the shooter to break position slightly to oxygenate if winded.

Four-inch,-three-shot-group-at-120-yards-from-Sitting-High-Knee-with-S&W-Model-69
Four-inch, three-shot group at 120 yards from Sitting High Knee with S&W Model 69.

GOING HOT

I worked the three sitting positions over several range sessions to demonstrate the potential. Handguns were a Glock 34 9mm to represent the service application and a Smith & Wesson Model 69 .44 Magnum (HITTING THE SWEET SPOT: Smith & Wesson Model 69 .44 Magnum, March 2015 S.W.A.T.) to showcase trail gun/ hunting scenarios. Ammunition was primarily Hornady 115-grain Critical Defense and 135-grain +P Critical Duty in 9mm and 225-grain Hornady LeverEvolution and Winchester Razorback in .44 Magnum.

I shot the handguns extensively at 75, 100, and 120 yards. Targets were an eight-inch plate at 75 yards, paper targets at 100, and a 16-inch steel silhouette at 120 yards. The eight-inch plate was tough, but I had no trouble getting hits with all three positions with either the G34 or Model 69. Much to my frustration, I haven’t put together five straight hits yet, but I rang the eightinch steel four for five on numerous occasions with both guns. Positions used on these runs were both the Sitting High Knee and Knee Straddle.

Paper at 100 was mostly used to verify holds and zero. Groups from the positions hovered around seven inches for the best four out of a five-shot group. Keeping hits in the “C” zone of a silhouette was a simple chore, with most falling into the ten-inch square B8 repair center target.

Actually needing to use a high-quality spotting scope to track hits was kind of funny while sitting in the dirt shooting handguns, challenging the norm.

The 120-yard silhouette looked a long way away once I focused on the front sight, but the positions kept the sights hovering neatly on target. From there it was just the discipline to break the shot cleanly. As with the 75- yard head plate, my most common result was four out of five “clang!” sounds drifting back. But I did have several “possibles” with both guns on the longest target.

The best of these 120-yard strings measured eight inches for five center hits with the 9mm and ten inches for the Hornady 225-grain .44 Magnums. The best three of the Magnum group measured an impressive four inches, well centered in the “A” zone! Both of these best groups came using the High Knee variation.

225-grain-.44-Magnum-and-+P-9mm-loads-fly-an-almost-identical-arc-to-the-target,-so-shooter-can-practice-the-same-holds-for-service-and-field-applications
225-grain .44 Magnum and +P 9mm loads fly an almost identical arc to the target, so shooter can practice the same holds for service and field applications. Left to right: Hornady 225-grain FTX, Winchester Razorback, Black Hills 124-grain +P, Hornady 135-grain +P Critical Duty.

MAX EFFECTIVE RANGE

I intentionally didn’t shoot past 120 yards for this article. Beyond that distance, factors converge to rapidly reduce probability. Yes, people hit farther all the time. Someone wins the lottery every day also, but that doesn’t make it a predictable outcome for you or me.

In my early experimentation with SHK, I once hit a 200-meter silhouette with four straight shots from a Smith M&P9 Compact and Black Hills 124-grain +Ps— a load that belly gun loves. All factors stacked in my favor that day, but I would be happy with any hit out of four on demand, and not surprised if none connected. Doing something once is an achievement—being able to do it on demand is a capability.

Many service pistols will plop five premium JHPs into a 2.25-inch average at 25 yards. They will often do this or better with several makes or grain weights. This would make a cone that extends out to 12 inches at 120 yards. Thus, a hit at 120 is entirely within the weapon’s envelope.

However, the issued pistol may not do that same 2.25-inch group with the issued ammo or a different lot of the previously good ammo. In this case, a good average for an ammo/pistol mismatch is probably about 3.5-inch groups at 25 yards. This works out to about 17 inches at 120 yards, or just barely on a typical frontal silhouette target.

This also assumes a perfect zero, which is a truly rare bird in the service pistol. Most pistols in the wild are one to three inches off the sights at 25 yards with whatever ammo is in the magazine, leading to bullets wandering off target at long range.

The ability to hold onto the target at a distinct aiming point is another large factor. The minute you have to hold over the target to compensate for bullet drop (or raise the front sight out of the notch), the probability of a hit drops precipitously. At 120 yards, handguns firing high-velocity cartridges sighted for the common six o’clock hold at 25 yards can hold high chest with plenty of target visible to confirm placement and still drop rounds into the good stuff.

The + P 9mm loads and the 225-grain .44 Magnum loads like the Hornady and Winchester fly an almost identical arc, allowing the same holds at most practical distances if the guns are zeroed similarly. Guns sighted for center at 25 yards and low-velocity cartridges sighted at six o’clock lose about 20 yards, maxing out at about 100 before the rounds start to drop off with a standard sight picture.

The best part of these three sitting positions is that they allow nearly the same grip on the handgun and the same relationship with the head as the shooter’s accustomed stance. The sitting just adds real stability. The shooter can apply almost all his practice into the long shot.

I have come to expect to be able to shoot groups that rival benched efforts from the sitting positions. However, it is just another tool. Sitting may not adapt to available cover or fit a given situation. But if it does, it allows some great shooting.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You May Also Like
Read More

Rangemaster on the Road: Instructor Development Class

When it comes to defensive firearm training geared specifically toward private citizens, I feel confident in stating that Tom Givens is one of the best instructors in the U.S. I can say this because I have been in his class, and because he has had over 60 of his non-LEO students prevail in shooting encounters with criminals.
Read More

Medic Up: Realistic Sensory Overload Training

"Medic Up!" The dreaded call comes over the sound of explosions and gunfire. I hurry through a smoky room, headed in the direction from which the call came. As I step through the doorway, a hand seizes the back of my collar, thrusting me to the floor. "They're shooting through here!" an operator yells. "Low crawl across!"